Posted On: January 31, 2011 by Ronald V. Miller, Jr.

Medical Device Approval and the 510(k) Process

In an article about what the FDA does not tell you, Smart Money tells us that 90% of medical devices approved by the FDA go through what is called a "510(k)" which allows device manufacturers to skip testing a device before putting it on the market if there is already a "similar device available."

I'm not saying necessarily that every medical device that has the slightest modification should have to jump through the full FDA approval process. I think few people are really saying that. The question is simply where do we draw the line and it seems fairly clear that we are drawing it in a way that makes it far too easy on medical device manufacturers.

The FDA recently took a shot at making the 510(k) device clearance process "more predictable and smarter" but has not made any real progress. Again, I understand their trepidation. We want to get products with slight improvements on the market quickly. I just think we have to (1) better define what qualifies for 510(k) and (2) intensify the requirement - something in the middle of full blown testing and "bring it on through."