Johnson & Johnson has agreed to pay about $600,000 to settle three, the first three, of approximately 8,000 lawsuits over hip implants that were recalled in 2010. The suits were scheduled to go to trial later this year.
J&J’s DePuy unit recalled approximately 93,000 ASR hips worldwide in 2010, saying that more than 12% of the devices failed within five year. The defective implants caused patients pain and immobilization by joint dislocations, as well as infections and bone fractures.
According to a university professor who follows the pharmaceutical industry, J&J should have expected to pay between 200k and 500k, so they were able to settle at the low end of what they should have expected to pay. What does he know? Probably not much. What I can tell you is that it is always easy to pick off a few plaintiffs and underpay on the claim as a way of getting plaintiffs’ lawyers thinking that the cases are worth less than they think. Good strategy on their part but let’s not fall for it. Some of these DePuy ASR cases are going to settle north of $1 million.
The company has said that it has spent about $800 million on the recall over the past two years, though it is being said that it may cost them as much as $2 billion in order to resolve all of the litigation over DePuy’s ASR hips.